The top 5 toasters that we tested

Small gadgets like toasters and toaster ovens are the unsung heroes of the industry. They are helpful for cooking sides when your main meal is hogging the oven, they can prevent your kitchen from scorching in the summer, and they allow you to cook a range of foods even if your living space is too small for a regular oven.

For the sake of this instruction, I used eight toaster ovens to roast, toast, air fry, and bake 32 pounds of chicken, eight dozen chocolate chip cookies, eight pizzas, and four loaves of bread. In addition, I sought the advice of Roxanne Wyss and Kathy Moore, who write under the moniker “The Electrified Cooks” and are the authors of the recently published toaster oven cookbook titled “Toaster Oven Takeover.”

Four years ago, I started reviewing kitchen appliances, and over that time, I devised a number of objective tests to evaluate which goods are the greatest fit for certain requirements and price points. This guide contains additional information on how I evaluated the toaster ovens that are discussed in the guide.

Best toaster oven overall

The top 5 toasters that we tested

Cuisinart Digital AirFryer Toaster Oven

Toast capacity: 6 slices
Pizza capacity: 12-inch
Convection/air fryer: Yes
Rack positions: 2
Interior dimensions: 12 x 12 x 5 inches
Exterior dimensions: 16 x 15.5 x 13.5 inches
Temperature range: 80 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Timer range: Up to two hours
Presets: Toast, bagel, bake, broil, pizza, roast, dehydrate, proof, low, airfry, reheat, warm
Extras: Extra oven rack, baking/drip pan, air frying basket, recipe booklet
Warranty: 3 years

In addition to functioning as both an air fryer and a dehydrator, the Cuisinart Digital AirFryer Toaster Oven maintains a steady heat to ensure that food is cooked swiftly and uniformly.

Pros: The advantages are that it is capable of convection cooking and air frying, it is big enough to accommodate a pizza with a diameter of 12 inches, it maintains a stable temperature, and it cooks foods like pizza, chicken, and cookies fast and evenly.

Cons: It seems like the temperature settings are off, and the bread did not toast evenly.

The Cuisinart Digital AirFryer Toaster Oven (Model TOA-65) had the best overall performance when put through our series of objective testing. It was ready to use in fewer than five minutes and had a digital display that was both illuminated and simple to see. You turn a knob and press it to select the setting and modify the time and temperature respectively. This is how you navigate through all of its many distinct functions.

One of the most reliable versions for baking cookies, pizza, and chicken was the toaster oven manufactured by Cuisinart. It took less than six minutes to heat up a frozen pizza, and the pepperoni, cheese, and crust all came out at the same temperature. The internal temperature of the chicken reached a safe level in 52 minutes when cooked with the convection function of the oven. Additionally, the skin turned a stunning golden brown color and tasted fantastic. The meat had a delicious flavor and was tender. Additionally, the baking time for the cookies was approximately 12 minutes, which was considerably less than the standard time of 13 minutes and 45 seconds.

After running the Cuisinart Digital AirFryer Toaster Oven at 350 degrees for two hours, we saw that the temperature shifted by only four degrees throughout the course of that time. However, the display said that it had been preheated when the thermometer that we were using read 270. After eight minutes, the temperature reached 350 degrees after continuing to rise. The test was conducted at a temperature of 314, which is significantly lower than 350.

In two additional respects, the Cuisinart toaster oven was not quite up to the mark of absolute perfection. We toasted six pieces of bread using the presets, but at a lightning-fast speed of under three minutes, the top was lighter than the medium shading that we had set it to. In addition to this, the underside was uneven, with the middle being nearly charred while the edges barely browned. If I were to use this toaster oven for standard toasting, I would probably increase the amount of time I toasted each slice of bread and rotate it once during the process.

In conclusion, according to our tests, it took the Cuisinart longer than usual to reach 350 degrees Fahrenheit after being turned on. On the other hand, it reached 425 degrees really rapidly, making it an excellent temperature for frozen pizza.

Best cheap toaster oven

The top 5 toasters that we tested

Black+Decker Crisp 'N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven

Toast capacity: 6 slices
Pizza capacity: 11-inch
Convection/air fryer: Yes
Rack positions: 3
Interior dimensions: 12 x 11.5 x 5.5 inches
Exterior dimensions: 17.5 x 14 x 11 inches
Temperature range: “Warm” to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Timer range: Up to 60 minutes or stay on
Presets: Air fry, bake, broil, toast, keep warm
Extras: Baking pan and air fry basket
Warranty: 2 years

If you are looking for an affordable toaster oven that doesn’t skimp on performance, the Black+Decker Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven is an excellent choice. It has a quick preheating time and maintains temperatures precisely.

Pros: The timer has a stay-on function, the preheating and temperature settings are accurate, the cooking is even, it includes options for air frying and convection cooking, and it has a fast preheating time.

Cons: The toasting was uneven, and it was one of the slowest methods for roasting a chicken.

The Black+Decker Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven (Model TO3217SS) performed just as well as the other models reviewed in our guide, despite the fact that it costs less than a third of the price of those other models. We like that it features straightforward analog knob controls, a spacious interior, and the ability to perform convection cooking as well as air frying. In addition, it is a wonderful touch that the timer has a “remain on” option, which eliminates the need to constantly adding extra time when the cooking process takes a longer amount of time.

It seems that the thermostat on the Black+Decker toaster oven was the most precise of the bunch. During the course of our two-hour test, the temperature got the closest to averaging 350 degrees when it reached 347. However, there was a difference of 13 degrees, which put it in the center of the pack for temperature variation.

It was consistently one of the quickest to get to the desired temperature. In fewer than four minutes, the temperature in the oven rose to 350 degrees, and the additional time needed to reach 425 degrees was only about a minute.

Cookies and frozen pizza came out exceptionally well when prepared in the Black+Decker Crisp ‘N Bake Air Fry Toaster Oven. The total baking time for each batch was about 14 minutes, which was about average; nonetheless, the results were uniform and tasty. The same thing happened with frozen pizza; the amount of time needed to cook it was about average, but the quality of the pizza itself was exceptional. The chicken was delicious as well: juicy, tasty, and well cooked throughout. However, completion of the model took about an hour and a half, making it one of the models with the slowest processing times.

The toasting capabilities of the Black+Decker oven were lacking. About took it three and a half minutes to toast six pieces of bread, which is approximately the same amount of time as the average, but the results weren’t very even. The toast’s top was pretty much uniform throughout, but the front was visibly underdone, and the bottom was significantly less toasted than the top. Overall, the toast was pretty good.

The most efficient toasting oven with a huge capacity

The top 5 toasters that we tested

Breville Smart Oven

Toast capacity: 9 slices
Pizza capacity: 12-inch
Convection/air fryer: Yes
Rack positions: 3
Interior dimensions: 13.5 x 12.5 x 5.5 inches
Exterior dimensions: 18.5 x 15.7 x 11.1 inches
Temperature range: 120 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Timer range: Up to two hours
Presets: Toast, bagel, bake, roast, broil, pizza, cookies, reheat, warm, slow cook, convection
Extras: Broil rack, baking pan, pizza pan
Warranty: 1 year

Because it can accommodate items such as nine slices of toast, a dozen cookies, or a 12-inch pizza, the Breville Smart Oven is an excellent choice for households with multiple members or for those who want to use it in place of their regular oven.

Pros: The advantages include that it can accommodate nine slices of toast as well as a pizza measuring 12 inches in diameter, that it provides consistent and even heat, that it has convection cooking as well as air frying capabilities, and that it has an attractive backlit digital display with a number of functions and sub-functions.

Cons: The temperature settings were always higher than what we measured, and it took a long time for the device to preheat.

The Breville Smart Oven (Model BOV800XL) was one of two models that could toast nine pieces of bread at simultaneously, and it did an excellent job of doing so. The other model was our top pick for the best combination, which can be found below. In addition to that, it has enough room for a pizza that is 12.5 inches in diameter. This is quite remarkable taking into consideration that the outer dimensions aren’t overly excessively enormous.

The Breville Smart Oven, just like our top option, includes a digital display that is backlit along with separate knobs that allow for speedy adjustment of the function, temperature, and time. Additionally, it possesses sub-functions that modify the amount of time spent cooking as well as the temperature based on the size of the pizza that is being baked or the slices of toast that are being toasted. In addition to that, the Smart Oven is capable of convection cooking and air frying.

The chicken and the cookies came out quite well from the oven. Roasting a full chicken took a little over an hour, but the resulting chicken had the best flavor and was cooked most uniformly of all the birds we tested. We used the Cookie feature of the spacious Breville Smart Oven, which involved convection cooking at a temperature of 350 degrees Fahrenheit. In total, we baked a dozen cookies at once. The cookies took about the typical amount of time, 14 minutes, to bake evenly throughout.

The pizza was cooked properly in the oven as well, however it took 17 minutes, which was significantly longer than all of the other models save for one. It was also one of the ovens that heated up the least quickly. In addition, we were unable to get it to preheat to the desired temperature of 425 degrees. The highest possible score was 387. This was an ongoing source of contention. Despite having the controls set to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, we only measured an average temperature of 292 degrees when we ran our temperature variance test. Because of this, we strongly advise making use of an oven thermometer when determining the appropriate temperature setting for your dish.

The positive aspect is that the Breville toaster oven was able to maintain its temperature with only a slight shift of four degrees after being used for two hours.

The toaster oven with the best combination of air frying and convection

The top 5 toasters that we tested

Anova Precision Oven

Toast capacity: 9 slices
Pizza capacity: 12-inch
Convection/air fryer: Yes
Rack positions: 5
Interior dimensions: 16.9 x 12.4 x 10 inches
Exterior dimensions: 22.4 x 17.7 x 14.1 inches
Temperature range: 77 to 482 degrees Fahrenheit
Timer range: Up to 99 hours
Presets: Virtually limitless using the Anova Oven app (available for iOS and Android)
Extras: Probe thermometer that connects to the oven, extra oven rack, and baking pan
Warranty: 2 years

The Anova Precision Oven is capable of baking, toasting, and air frying in addition to offering sous vide cooking, and you can use your phone to control the oven as well as monitor the temperature of the interior of the food you are preparing.

Pros: Includes sous vide and air fryer/convection cooking capabilities, smart WiFi connectivity with the use of an accompanying app, comes with a probe thermometer that can be connected to the oven, and roasts food to a satisfactory level.

Cons: It took a long time to preheat, bake, and toast, and the temperature didn’t remain stable while we were testing it.

The Anova Precision Oven is the first toaster oven available on the market that is capable of air frying and convection cooking in addition to the sous vide technique. In addition, unlike the majority of sous vide appliances call for the food to be vacuum-sealed before cooking, the Precision Oven can prepare food without the need for any additional packaging.

The sous-vide capability allowed me to prepare a number of steaks and pork ribs, and I discovered that it worked just as well as, if not better than, an immersion circulator. To monitor the internal temperature of the meat as it cooked, which is something that cannot be done with vacuum-sealed meat when using an immersion circulator, I found it especially convenient that the oven comes with a probe thermometer that can be plugged into the unit and used to do the monitoring.

The touch buttons on the handle of the oven are not as responsive as I would like them to be, and it is a nuisance to adjust the temperature by one degree at a time using the up and down buttons. As a result, I relied primarily on the Anova Oven app, which is compatible with both iOS and Android and lets you enter the temperature and cooking time that you desire. Alternately, the process of cooking could be computerized. The app has a huge variety of different recipes. When I was in the grocery store waiting in line to pay for a frozen pizza, I pulled up the app on my phone and preheated the oven so that it would be ready to put the pizza in when I got home.

Given that the Anova Culinary Precision Oven was one of the models that took the longest to warm up, this function is really essential. Ten minutes are needed to bring the temperature up to 350 degrees, and another 17 minutes are needed to achieve 425 degrees.

During our test period of two hours, the temperature fluctuated by 16 degrees, which is more than most other models do and despite the fact that it has a setpoint that is rather reliable.

Toasting takes a considerable amount of time in the Anova Precision Oven. We selected the toast preset, which included the use of some steam in order to prevent the bread from being overly dry. The method, on the other hand, took significantly more time than any of the other models, and the toast came out underdone.

It was much more successful with the other types of cookery. The Anova oven has room for a dozen cookies, and the baking process is swift and even for all of them. When it came to pizza, we had the same experience: cooking was quick and consistent. However, the oven did a fantastic job of cooking an entire chicken. It finished the job in a little less than an hour. The flesh was succulent and savory, and the skin was perfectly crispy and seasoned. The feature of the thermometer that allowed me to check the interior temperature of the chicken through the app was one of my favorites.

Best tiny toaster oven

The top 5 toasters that we tested

Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven

Toast capacity: 4 slices
Pizza capacity: 9-inch
Convection/air fryer: No
Rack positions: 2
Interior dimensions: 10.5 x 9 x 4 inches
Exterior dimensions: 15 x 11.5 x 8.7 inches
Temperature range: 150 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit
Timer range: Stay on and up to 30 minutes
Presets: Roast, toast, bake
Extras: Broiling/baking pan
Warranty: 1 year

The fact that the Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven is on the smaller side is also one of its selling points because it heats up in a hurry, requires very little room on the countertop, and is inexpensive.

Pros: Quickly preheats, is inexpensive, has a compact footprint, and has a timer that stays on.

Cons: It took the greatest amount of time to prepare pizza, cookies, and chicken; it can only fit a pizza that is 9 inches or less.

Even though it was the most compact model we tried, the Hamilton Beach Countertop Toaster Oven (model 31401) did a fantastic job of distributing heat evenly throughout the cooking process. In all of our tests, it was one of the fastest to preheat due to the fact that the inside was rather small. And with a price tag of $70, it comes in at about the same level as our budget pick.

The temperature, the amount of time, and the function can all be adjusted with the help of just three dials on the Hamilton Beach toaster oven. You are free to leave the oven on even as the timer is counting down the thirty minutes remaining on its countdown. When roasting a chicken, which took nearly two hours total, a half hour longer than any other model, this came in helpful. In comparison to the other ovens, the pizza and cookies took around 5 and 4 minutes longer, respectively.

The dinner turned out to be delicious, in spite of the prolonged cooking periods. Both the pizza and the cookies had a consistent level of doneness. The chicken had a succulent flavor. The toasting went quickly and evenly, but you had to turn the bread over halfway through so that all sides get the same color.

In terms of temperature variance, the Hamilton Beach 31401 only managed to achieve an average score. During the course of the test that lasted for two hours, the temperature inside the oven only moved by 6.3 degrees, but it remained roughly 30 degrees below the target temperature of 350 degrees.

Toaster oven FAQs

What are the advantages of utilizing a toaster oven as opposed to a conventional oven?

Toaster ovens are more environmentally friendly than traditional ovens since they heat up more quickly, as noted by Roxanne Wyss, co-author of the toaster oven cookbook “Toaster Oven Takeover.” Wyss noted that toaster ovens are speedier at preheating. You also won’t need to bend over to use them because they are designed to be placed on a countertop.

When I go shopping for a toaster oven, what characteristics should I look for?

It was recommended by Kathy Moore, co-author of the cookbook “Toaster Oven Takeover,” to think about what you want to cook in your toaster oven as well as where the food will go after it is cooked. You need to choose a device that will fit, and you don’t want to overpay for additional capabilities that you won’t ever make use of.

What kinds of foods can be cooked in a toaster oven?

Toasting, broiling, roasting, and baking are just some of the capabilities of a toaster oven. You may also air fry using a toaster oven that has a convection setting. We recommend that you use a toaster oven instead of a regular oven whenever it is possible so that you can save some energy.

Is it a good idea to invest in a toaster oven?

It is money well spent to purchase a toaster oven, especially when one of our multifunctional budget picks only costs $70. A toaster oven is a good option to go with when you want to bake or toast but don’t have room for an actual oven. Additionally, it functions as both a toaster and an air fryer.

How long do toaster ovens typically stay functional?

Every recommendation in this list comes with a guarantee that is at least one year long, with the exception of our top option, which has a warranty that is good for three years. If you clean your toaster oven regularly and empty its crumb tray, you may expect it to last for several years. This is especially true if you wipe it down and keep it free of crumbs.

You may also like

Proofreader at KEWIKI

Eirlys here. I'm a writer with a keen eye for detail and a talent for weaving words together to create something truly special. From a young age, I've been fascinated by the way words can be used to paint a picture, to tell a story, to convey an emotion. I've always been drawn to the beauty and complexity of language, and I feel incredibly fortunate to be able to make a career out of it. My goal as a writer is to create work that is both accessible and profound, that speaks to the human experience in a way that is both relatable and illuminating.

Proofreader at KEWIKI

Sariel Gomez, a writer who is passionate about using the power of the written word to create change and make a difference. I believe that writing is not just about expressing oneself, but about using words to inspire others and to make a positive impact on the world. I strive to create stories that are both impactful and meaningful, that inspire readers to take action and to make a difference. I believe that writing has the power to change the world, and I am honored to be a part of that tradition.


Latest articles

How to Mindfulness Meditate: A Beginner’s Guide

Discover the benefits of mindfulness meditation with this beginner's guide. Learn tips and techniques for cultivating a calmer, more focused mind through daily practice.

Review of Nothing Ear 2: It’s what’s inside that matters

Back in 2021, Carl Pei, co-founder of OnePlus, was...

GPT-4: The Future of Artificial Intelligence?

In this article, we explore the potential of GPT-4, the next generation of AI language models. We discuss its advanced algorithms, potential applications, ethical concerns, and limitations, along with frequently asked questions about the technology.

Disclosure: Written and researched by the KEWIKI crew. We spotlight services and products you may discover fascinating. If you happen to purchase them, we could get a small share of the income from the sale from our companions. We could obtain merchandise freed from cost from producers to test. This doesn't drive our resolution as to whether a product is featured or beneficial. We function independently from our promoting group. We welcome your suggestions. Please e-mail us at [email protected] 


find out more!